Utility Deep-Dive · Con Edison New York · Residential Rate Analysis
Con Edison New York residential EV rate analysis
For residential electric vehicle (EV) owners in Con Edison's New York City and Westchester County service territory, the base electricity rate structure fundamentally shapes charging economics.
Drive Economics has no affiliation with, sponsorship from, or endorsement by Consolidated Edison, Inc., Con Edison of New York, the New York State Public Service Commission, or any other utility or government agency named here.
Con Edison serves approximately 1.4 million residential customers and operates in one of the highest-cost residential electricity territories in the US. The standard flat residential rate runs approximately $0.28 per kilowatt-hour all-in (combining supply and delivery components), while Rate III — Con Edison's whole-household time-of-use option — shifts the entire household's delivery rate based on time-of-use schedule, delivering approximately $0.17 per kilowatt-hour overnight off-peak but reaching approximately $0.42-$0.46 per kilowatt-hour during summer on-peak hours (a 50-80% premium above the standard rate during the peak window). The structural choice between the standard rate and Rate III is distinct from the SmartCharge NY rewards program decision — Rate III and SmartCharge NY are mutually exclusive, and the SmartCharge NY economics are covered in a dedicated companion deep-dive. This analysis focuses specifically on the base rate structure: standard rate composition, Rate III mechanics, the supply versus delivery split, NY Energy Choice third-party supplier dynamics, annual household economics scenarios, and comparative positioning against peer utility residential rates.
The short answer
Con Edison residential rates are among the highest in the US, which fundamentally changes EV economics in both directions. The standard flat residential rate at approximately $0.28 per kilowatt-hour all-in is substantially above the US residential average of approximately $0.17 per kilowatt-hour. High absolute rates mean EV charging costs more in Con Edison territory than in most US regions, but also mean that any rate optimization — whether through Rate III timing discipline, third-party supply arrangements, or SmartCharge NY participation — delivers proportionally larger dollar savings. In practice, Con Edison customers have more to gain from active rate management than customers in lower-cost territories.
Rate III is a whole-household TOU option, not an EV-only rate — which creates both opportunity and risk. Rate III restructures the entire household's delivery rate around a time-of-use schedule rather than isolating EV charging on a submeter. Off-peak hours (overnight, 12 AM to 8 AM) carry substantially discounted rates, approximately $0.17 per kilowatt-hour. On-peak hours (2 PM to 10 PM weekdays, with higher summer rates during peak summer months) carry a substantial premium above the standard flat rate — approximately $0.42-$0.46 per kilowatt-hour during summer on-peak. For households that reliably shift substantial consumption (including EV charging, dishwashing, laundry, and some HVAC) to off-peak hours, Rate III produces meaningful net savings. For households whose consumption patterns cannot avoid the summer afternoon peak window, Rate III can produce net losses relative to the standard rate.
The supply versus delivery split means third-party supply arrangements can further optimize for well-informed households. Con Edison bills separate the energy supply charge (the kilowatt-hours of electricity itself) from the delivery charge (transmission, distribution, and system infrastructure). Supply rates can be sourced from Con Edison's default Basic Service or from licensed New York Energy Choice third-party suppliers offering fixed-price contracts, index-based pricing, or renewable energy products. Delivery charges remain with Con Edison regardless of supply source. For customers in Rate III specifically, careful matching of supply timing (fixed vs market-indexed) with Rate III's delivery TOU structure can produce substantial additional savings beyond the rate structure alone.
Rate III and SmartCharge NY are mutually exclusive — the choice between them is one of the most important rate decisions Con Edison residential EV customers face. Customers cannot stack Rate III's whole-household TOU structure with SmartCharge NY's per-kilowatt-hour rewards. The SmartCharge NY program excludes customers currently on Rate III or Rate III-equivalent TOU rates. For most residential EV households, SmartCharge NY delivers greater net value than Rate III due to its approximately $400 per year average participation value and favorable off-peak rewards structure; see the dedicated SmartCharge NY analysis for program-specific economics. For households with substantial non-EV off-peak consumption potential (electric heat, electric water heating, programmable appliances), Rate III may still deliver better whole-household economics than SmartCharge NY's EV-specific rewards.
1.4M+
Residential customers in Con Edison territory
~$0.28
Standard flat rate all-in per kWh (approximate)
~$0.17
Rate III off-peak overnight per kWh (approximate)
50-80%
Rate III summer on-peak premium above standard
Why Con Edison territory base rates matter structurally for EV economics
Con Edison's residential rate structure is distinctive among US investor-owned utilities in three ways that materially affect EV charging economics. First, the absolute rate level is substantially above the US residential average — approximately $0.28 per kilowatt-hour all-in versus a US average of approximately $0.17 per kilowatt-hour. The high absolute rate means that EV charging costs more per mile in Con Edison territory than in most US regions, which can affect vehicle total cost of ownership calculations and the EV versus gasoline value proposition.
Second, Con Edison's rate structure explicitly separates supply from delivery. Supply charges reflect wholesale energy procurement costs and can fluctuate substantially across seasons and market conditions. Delivery charges reflect transmission, distribution, and local system infrastructure costs. Each component contributes approximately half of the total residential rate, and each has distinct optimization levers available to customers. Supply can be sourced from third-party suppliers under New York Energy Choice; delivery stays with Con Edison but can be optimized through rate structure selection (standard vs Rate III).
Third, Con Edison's service territory includes some of the hottest summer weather patterns in the US Northeast urban corridor. Peak summer afternoon demand creates stress on the local grid that drives Rate III's significant summer on-peak pricing premium. The combination of high absolute rates, substantial seasonal variability, and TOU structural options means Con Edison residential EV customers have substantially more active rate management opportunity than customers in flat-rate territories — and more downside risk from poor rate management.
The analysis below works through the standard residential rate composition, Rate III mechanics in detail, the supply versus delivery split and NY Energy Choice considerations, the summer heat factor affecting Rate III economics, annual household economics scenarios across typical EV consumption patterns, and comparative positioning against peer utility residential rates. For SmartCharge NY-specific analysis, including program rewards structure and comparative positioning against peer utility managed charging programs, see the dedicated Con Edison SmartCharge NY deep-dive.
Standard residential rate: structure and composition
The default Con Edison residential rate is a flat all-in rate (no time-of-use variation) applied to the household's total kilowatt-hour consumption. The approximately $0.28 per kilowatt-hour all-in rate reflects the sum of supply charges (wholesale energy procurement, typically $0.10-$0.14 per kilowatt-hour depending on season and market conditions) plus delivery charges (transmission, distribution, system benefits, and various riders, typically $0.14-$0.16 per kilowatt-hour). The specific split varies by billing period and market conditions, but the all-in rate consistently places Con Edison among the most expensive US residential electricity territories.
Three structural characteristics of the standard rate affect EV charging decisions. First, there is no TOU incentive — charging at 3 AM costs the same as charging at 3 PM. Overnight charging is still operationally preferred for most households (vehicle at home, L2 charger connected), but the standard rate does not create any economic incentive to time-shift. Second, the standard rate is the required baseline for SmartCharge NY participation — customers cannot participate in SmartCharge NY while on Rate III. Third, the standard rate allows the greatest flexibility for third-party supply arrangements, as the rate structure does not require coordination with delivery TOU timing.
The chart below shows the typical composition of the standard residential rate across supply and delivery components.
Con Edison standard residential rate composition · supply vs delivery breakdown
Swipe to see the full chart →
Rate III whole-household TOU: structure and mechanics
Rate III is Con Edison's voluntary residential time-of-use rate option, available as an alternative to the standard flat residential rate. The structural distinction from the standard rate is that Rate III applies TOU pricing to the entire household's delivery charges — not just to EV charging on a submeter, and not combined with the SmartCharge NY cash rewards program. The household's complete electricity consumption, from refrigerator to air conditioning to water heater to EV charging, is billed at TOU rates that vary by time of day and season.
Three structural characteristics define Rate III mechanics:
Three-tier time structure: Super-off-peak hours (12 AM to 8 AM, every day) carry the lowest delivery rates — approximately $0.17 per kilowatt-hour all-in including supply. Off-peak shoulder hours (8 AM to 2 PM, and 10 PM to 12 AM, Monday through Friday, plus all weekend hours) carry moderate rates — typically close to the standard rate. On-peak hours (2 PM to 10 PM Monday through Friday) carry a substantial premium above the standard rate.
Seasonal variation: Summer on-peak rates (approximately June through September) are substantially higher than winter on-peak rates, reflecting the dramatic increase in grid stress during NYC summer afternoon demand peaks. Winter on-peak rates run approximately $0.30-$0.35 per kilowatt-hour all-in; summer on-peak rates reach approximately $0.42-$0.46 per kilowatt-hour all-in.
Whole-household scope: Unlike EV-specific TOU rates offered by some utilities, Rate III applies to the entire household electrical panel. The household cannot segregate EV charging on a separate meter for Rate III billing while keeping other consumption on the standard rate.
The practical consequence is that Rate III household economics depend on the household's ability to shift substantial consumption out of the summer afternoon on-peak window — not just EV charging, but air conditioning, cooking, laundry, dishwashing, and other time-flexible loads. For households that reliably achieve this shift, Rate III produces substantial net savings. For households with inflexible on-peak consumption patterns, Rate III can produce net losses.
Con Edison Rate III structure · time-of-use pricing by period and season
Swipe to see the full chart →
Three observations about the Rate III structure. First, the super-off-peak window from 12 AM to 8 AM every day provides a substantial discount regardless of season — approximately 39% below the standard flat rate. For households with EV charging patterns that fit the overnight window, this delivers meaningful savings against charging-related consumption. Second, the summer on-peak window (2 PM to 10 PM weekdays, June through September) carries a dramatic premium reaching approximately $0.44 per kilowatt-hour all-in — approximately 57% above the standard flat rate. Non-trivial household consumption during this window can quickly offset savings earned during off-peak hours. Third, weekend rates stay close to the standard flat rate throughout both seasons, which effectively reduces discipline requirements for two days per week.
The supply vs delivery split: NY Energy Choice considerations
New York State operates a deregulated residential electricity market under the New York Energy Choice program. Residential customers may receive electricity supply from Con Edison's default Basic Service or from any licensed New York Energy Choice third-party supplier. Supply charges reflect wholesale energy procurement costs and can be contracted at fixed prices, variable market-indexed prices, or specialty rates such as 100% renewable energy premiums. Delivery charges remain with Con Edison regardless of supply source.
Three strategic considerations shape the supply decision for Con Edison residential EV customers:
Default Basic Service tracks wholesale market conditions. Con Edison's default supply rate reflects pass-through wholesale electricity costs, which vary substantially across seasons and market conditions. For customers who prefer stable monthly bills, a fixed-price third-party contract eliminates supply rate variability. For customers comfortable with market-tracking pricing, Basic Service often produces competitive outcomes over long horizons.
Fixed-price contracts carry contract-term risk. Third-party fixed-price supply contracts typically run 12 to 36 months at a price agreed at contract signing. If wholesale electricity prices fall during the contract term, the customer pays above market; if prices rise, the customer benefits. Contract early-termination fees typically apply, limiting flexibility to switch suppliers if market conditions change.
Rate III timing interacts with supply contract structure. Rate III customers who contract fixed-price supply are effectively insulated from supply volatility but still face delivery TOU pricing variability. Rate III customers using variable-price or index-based supply face both supply and delivery TOU pricing variability simultaneously. For disciplined households with strong overnight charging patterns, both approaches can work; for less-disciplined households, the stability of fixed supply plus standard delivery rate is often the simpler choice.
For most residential EV customers, the supply decision is secondary to the rate structure decision (standard vs Rate III vs SmartCharge NY). Customers should first decide the rate structure that fits their consumption pattern, then layer the supply decision on top. Switching supply arrangements is operationally straightforward and can be done without changing rate class.
The New York summer heat factor
New York City summer weather creates a specific risk pattern for Rate III customers that does not apply in cooler peer utility territories. The 2 PM to 10 PM summer on-peak window coincides with the hottest hours of the day during the peak NYC summer season, when air conditioning load is at maximum and household electricity consumption cannot be meaningfully shifted off-peak.
Three practical consequences for Rate III household economics:
Air conditioning cannot be time-shifted. Residential air conditioning operates in response to actual indoor temperature conditions, not to electricity rate signals. On the hottest NYC summer afternoons when outdoor temperatures exceed 90°F, residential AC systems operate continuously regardless of Rate III's on-peak pricing. The resulting on-peak kilowatt-hour consumption at approximately $0.44 per kilowatt-hour can accumulate substantially over the summer months.
Work-from-home patterns have shifted summer afternoon consumption upward. Residential daytime electricity consumption has increased substantially since 2020 as work-from-home arrangements place more workers at home during on-peak hours. Home office equipment, kitchen use during lunch, and incidental daytime consumption all contribute to on-peak kilowatt-hour volume that was lower in the pre-2020 commuting pattern. For Rate III households this translates to higher summer on-peak exposure than historical patterns would suggest.
Multi-household buildings may have shared loads reducing individual AC exposure. Residents of larger apartment buildings with central cooling systems or shared HVAC may have lower individual AC exposure than suburban single-family households with per-unit systems. For urban multifamily tenants, the summer peak risk is somewhat lower; for Westchester suburban customers in detached homes, the risk is higher.
The practical rule is that Rate III works best for households that can genuinely minimize summer afternoon consumption (homes without AC, homes with central AC that operates predominantly overnight, or homes with minimal daytime occupancy). For households with substantial unavoidable summer afternoon AC load, the standard flat rate often produces better whole-household economics than Rate III, even accounting for the overnight EV charging savings.
Annual household economics scenarios
Translating the standard rate and Rate III options into household impact requires combining base consumption patterns with EV charging. The following four scenarios bracket typical Con Edison residential EV customer outcomes, using a reference household of a 2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range driven 12,000 miles per year (3,120 kilowatt-hours annual EV charging) plus a representative household base consumption of 8,000 kilowatt-hours per year (approximately the Con Edison residential average).
Four scenarios bracket realistic outcomes:
Annual household electricity cost · four Con Edison rate scenarios
Swipe to see the full chart →
The scenarios illustrate Rate III's central characteristic: the outcome depends heavily on household discipline. Scenario B (disciplined off-peak) delivers substantial savings relative to the standard flat baseline. Scenario C (moderate discipline) still outperforms the standard rate, confirming that Rate III generally produces positive outcomes for households that put reasonable effort into timing consumption. Scenario D (poor discipline with summer AC heavy consumption) actually costs more than the standard flat rate — the summer on-peak premium accumulates faster than the overnight savings for households that cannot avoid afternoon consumption.
Two practical heuristics emerge from the scenario analysis. First, Rate III generally works for Con Edison residential EV households that charge overnight consistently and have moderate or lower summer afternoon AC exposure. Second, Rate III is specifically risky for households with substantial summer afternoon AC consumption that cannot be shifted — particularly suburban Westchester customers in detached homes with central AC and daytime occupancy patterns.
The Rate III vs SmartCharge NY decision
For Con Edison residential EV customers, the most consequential rate decision is often between Rate III and SmartCharge NY. The two paths are mutually exclusive — customers cannot stack the Rate III whole-household TOU structure with SmartCharge NY's per-kilowatt-hour cash rewards. SmartCharge NY requires customers to be on the standard flat residential rate.
The companion Con Edison SmartCharge NY deep-dive covers the SmartCharge program in detail (approximately $400 per year average participation value, three distinct reward components including off-peak charging reward, summer peak avoidance bonus, and onboarding bonuses, monthly PayPal or Venmo payouts, ev.energy platform administration). For the Rate III vs SmartCharge decision specifically, three structural considerations guide the choice:
SmartCharge NY generally produces greater net value for most Con Edison residential EV households. SmartCharge NY's approximately $400 per year average participation value substantially exceeds the typical Rate III household savings relative to the standard flat rate (approximately $200-$400 per year for households with reasonable discipline). SmartCharge NY's rewards are explicitly structured for EV charging and layered on top of the standard flat rate without TOU exposure to summer afternoon AC consumption.
Rate III can produce greater value for households with substantial time-flexible non-EV consumption. Households with electric heat, electric water heating, programmable appliances, and consumption patterns that can genuinely shift to overnight hours may capture more whole-household savings on Rate III than SmartCharge NY delivers on EV-only rewards. These households are a minority of residential EV customers but represent the specific case where Rate III wins.
The choice is reversible but adds administrative friction. Customers may switch between Rate III and standard rate (and reenroll in SmartCharge NY) based on operational preference, but each transition requires administrative processing and may introduce brief gaps in optimization. Customers who are uncertain which path fits best should model both carefully before committing, then monitor outcomes over a full year before switching.
How Con Edison compares to peer utility residential rates
Con Edison's residential rates sit at the high end of the US residential electricity rate landscape. The chart below compares all-in residential rates across representative peer utilities, with Con Edison's standard flat rate highlighted.
Residential electricity rate comparison · Con Edison vs peer utilities
Swipe to see the full chart →
Three observations about Con Edison's peer positioning. First, the standard flat rate at approximately $0.28 per kilowatt-hour is substantially above the US residential average of approximately $0.17 per kilowatt-hour, and comparable to the highest-rate US residential territories (Massachusetts utilities and parts of California). Second, Rate III's off-peak rate at approximately $0.17 per kilowatt-hour drops to approximately the US residential average — a disciplined Rate III customer pays similar rates to the typical US household during off-peak hours, but faces substantial penalty exposure during on-peak hours. Third, Con Edison's territory consistently sits approximately 1.6 to 1.8 times the Pennsylvania residential utility rates covered in companion Drive Economics analyses, which translates directly to higher per-mile EV charging cost for Con Edison customers — and correspondingly higher dollar value from any optimization strategy.
Further economic considerations
Several additional factors shape whether Con Edison residential rate choices deliver headline value for specific households.
Rate structure is reversible but introduces administrative friction. Customers may switch between the standard rate, Rate III, and SmartCharge NY enrollment, but each transition requires administrative processing through Con Edison's customer service and may introduce brief gaps in optimization during the switchover. Customers uncertain which path fits best should model both carefully using representative household consumption data before committing, then monitor actual outcomes over a full annual cycle (including a summer season) before switching.
Submetering and separately metered EV charging is generally not available for standard residential service. Unlike some peer utility territories (particularly in California) where EV-only submeters allow isolated TOU pricing for charging consumption, Con Edison's residential rate structure does not generally support separate submetering for EV charging. The whole-household rate structure (standard or Rate III) applies to the complete household electrical panel. This limits the ability to optimize EV charging on a separate rate from household consumption.
Multi-family tenants face additional structural considerations. Residents of large apartment buildings with central house meters, shared electrical panels, or landlord-controlled electricity accounts may not have individual Rate III eligibility or SmartCharge NY participation ability. For multifamily tenants, the operational practicalities of EV charging economics depend substantially on building electrical configuration and lease terms. Direct-metered multifamily residents in Con Edison territory have the same options as single-family customers; master-metered or sub-metered residents may be structurally limited.
Rate structures and specific per-kilowatt-hour values are subject to NY State Public Service Commission rate case activity. Con Edison files residential rate cases with the New York State Public Service Commission periodically; approved rate changes can shift the specific supply charges, delivery charges, Rate III period definitions, and all-in rates over time. Historical rate structure continuity has been reasonably stable, but prospective residential EV customers should verify current rates at the point of rate class selection or SmartCharge enrollment.
Summer wholesale market dynamics can affect Basic Service supply rates substantially. Hot summer months typically see elevated wholesale electricity prices in the NYC area due to the combination of regional air conditioning load and transmission constraints into New York City. For customers on Con Edison Basic Service supply, the resulting supply rate increases can push total monthly bills above the all-in approximations used in this analysis. Third-party fixed-price supply contracts eliminate this seasonal variability but at a long-term cost that may or may not favor the customer depending on market conditions.
EV charging represents a modest share of total residential electricity consumption. For the reference household at 3,120 kilowatt-hours annual EV charging against 8,000 kilowatt-hours base consumption, EV charging represents approximately 28% of total household electricity use. Rate optimization strategies that improve EV-specific economics may still produce poor whole-household outcomes if the strategies worsen the economics of the 72% of consumption that is not EV charging. This is specifically what distinguishes Rate III's whole-household impact from SmartCharge NY's EV-only impact.
Method. Con Edison residential rate structure (standard flat rate approximately $0.28 per kilowatt-hour all-in, Rate III whole-household time-of-use rate with super-off-peak at approximately $0.17 per kilowatt-hour from 12 AM to 8 AM every day, shoulder periods at approximately $0.24-$0.27 per kilowatt-hour depending on season, on-peak at approximately $0.32 per kilowatt-hour winter and $0.44 per kilowatt-hour summer during 2 PM to 10 PM Monday through Friday, weekend rates close to shoulder level) reflects approximate values representative of Con Edison residential tariff structure as of 2026. Specific supply charges vary with wholesale market conditions; delivery charges are set through NY State Public Service Commission rate case proceedings. Reference household uses a 2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range at 12,000 miles per year (3,120 kilowatt-hours annual EV charging) plus 8,000 kilowatt-hours annual base household consumption consistent with Con Edison residential averages. Scenario math assumes different distributions of consumption across the Rate III time periods representing different household discipline levels. Peer utility rate comparison reflects current approximate all-in residential rate ranges as of Q3 2026; peer rates change through rate case activity. NY Energy Choice supply options reflect current deregulated market structure; specific third-party supplier offerings vary. Rate III and SmartCharge NY mutual exclusivity reflects current Con Edison program design. All numbers are estimates for guidance; actual outcomes depend on specific household consumption patterns, discipline, current rates, and SmartCharge NY participation level.
Model your household's Con Edison economics
Use the EV Cost calculator to project annual charging cost for your specific vehicle and mileage in Con Edison territory. The Utility Rates browser shows comparable residential rate structures across other US territories. The companion SmartCharge NY analysis covers the rewards program alternative to Rate III.